The Green Scramble

How global net zero ambitions corrupt African land rights

Bonthe Island, 83 miles south of Freetown, Sierra Leone
Bonthe Island, 83 miles south of Freetown, Sierra LeoneCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

If Freetown, Sierra Leone’s capital, has a pulse, you can feel it at Congo Cross Junction.

The critical traffic intersection, air thick with exhaust fumes and dust, is a place where scrap metal traders move, loved ones meet and buses re-fuel before traversing the city peninsular. Nearby, in a small room - bathed in bluish fluorescent light - a group of lawyers have gathered to explain to us the work they are doing to protect Sierra Leone’s climate future. The topic of the day: Carbon credits.

“The reality is carbon investments are relatively new. What we've been used to for the past 100 years is mining and plantation agriculture”, explains Sonkita Conteh, lawyer and co-founder of Namati Sierra Leone, an organisation using the law to advance environmental and social justice causes. Namati advises communities affected by new carbon credit projects. For Conteh, these projects are a chance to show that investment and fairness can go together. “We want to make this work because we want to show the government that investment in this day and age is not just about mining and monocrop plantation," he tells us, “When we saw that opportunity, we jumped right at it.“

A community member living by the Gola Rainforest National Park buffer zone, Sierra Leone - a beneficiary of the Gola REDD carbon credits project
A community member living by the Gola Rainforest National Park buffer zone, Sierra Leone - a beneficiary of the Gola REDD carbon credits projectCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

The carbon credit market is a multi-billion-dollar industry that is growing rapidly across Africa - in many countries with little to no regulation. Lawyers like Sonkita are working to support fair process as deals are struck and projects initiated.

The principle is simple. One carbon credit stands for one tonne of carbon dioxide that has either been kept out of the atmosphere or removed from it. Projects that generate credits, for example by protecting a forest that would have otherwise been cut down, or by planting trees, can have their value impact calculated and certified by independent standards bodies. Each verified tonne becomes a credit that can be sold.

Companies often buy these credits to offset emissions that they cannot, or do not want to, reduce themselves. This way they can present parts of their business as “carbon neutral.” The money created by selling credits is meant to flow back into the projects and the communities around them. Within the voluntary carbon market, which this investigation focuses on, no law requires companies to buy credits. On paper, carbon credits offer an elegant way for companies to protect the environment, compensate for their carbon emissions and finance climate mitigation efforts. The market is swelling to meet the demand.

Political momentum around the world

Cumulative carbon-credit projects by regionLine chart, 2009 to 2026. Africa rises from 0 to 100 projects, with its largest yearly rise in 2020; Asia & Oceania reaches 299 and Latin America reaches 202.0100200300200920122015201820212026Africa 100Europe 28North America 35Asia & Oceania 299Latin America 202Cumulative carbon-credit projects by regionLine chart, 2009 to 2026. Africa rises from 0 to 100 projects, with its largest yearly rise in 2020; Asia & Oceania reaches 299 and Latin America reaches 202.010020030020092013201720212026Africa 100Europe 28North America 35Asia & Oceania 299Latin America 202
Cumulative carbon-credit projects by region. Source: Gold Standard and Verra (VCS) registries; Land Matrix — analysis by Christoph Kubitza
Show the data
Cumulative carbon-credit projects by region
YearAfricaEuropeNorth AmericaAsia & OceaniaLatin America
200900108
201000108
201140109
20121001214
20131401514
20141501714
20151801816
20161801820
201719011121
201819011124
201920011127
20205031859103
20215442187109
202256822131124
202367925170139
2024781326223155
2025941831268191
20261002835299202

Source: Gold Standard and Verra (VCS) registries; Land Matrix — analysis by Christoph Kubitza

In February 2026, the UN’s climate arm approved the first batch of credits issued under the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism, which allows carbon credits to be transferred between countries and, crucially, used toward national climate commitments. The EU has followed. Under its new climate law, from 2036, high-quality international credits may cover up to 5 percent of 1990 EU net emissions on the way to its 2040 target.

More demand means more projects, and they all need land. Africa, with its vast forests and savannahs, has become a prime destination. Critics have condemned the rush for African land as a new “scramble for Africa.” The phrase recalls the rapid and often brutal colonization of the continent by European powers at the end of the 19th century.

A number of important questions have emerged. Who controls the land where carbon credit projects are established? Who benefits from the money generated by their sale? And who bears the costs when things go wrong?

In Spring 2026, freelance reporters with Africa Uncensored and Deutsche Welle visited multiple projects in Sierra Leone, Uganda and Kenya - each with international investment or with international companies purchasing credits from the land. We wanted to understand these projects and their impact through the eyes of the communities themselves. For some, the investments brought hope. But for many others, the projects brought hardship, violence and a fight to protect their very way of life. These are their stories.

Hope, patience and mangroves - Sherbro Island, Sierra Leone

83 miles south of Freetown, extensive and tangled root networks of mangrove trees emerge from the mud to protect Sherbro Island - and its 40,000 scattered inhabitants - from the crashing Atlantic waves.

Sherbro Island, Sierra Leone. Open in OpenStreetMap © OpenStreetMap contributors
Mania Village, Sherbro Island
Mania Village, Sherbro IslandCredit: Saidu Bah

Sherbro Island, also known as Bonthe Island, is home to various informally constructed villages. Across the region, fishermen and their families reside largely removed from the commerce and development of the mainland. And it shows. There are no paved roads and no cars. Markets are accessible only by boat. In many villages, there is no cellphone reception. The ruins of colonial era buildings offer a glimpse of a different moment in Sierra Leone's history, one where Bonthe was a vibrant trading hub with a vital wartime naval base, too. But, today, in this area of economic isolation, Sherbro is, in its own way, a place forgotten by time.

One constant in Sherbro’s history, however, is the ancient and formidable ecosystem of mangroves. The dense roots and tree branches absorb wave energy and reduce storm surge heights from extreme weather. Their hard, water-resistant wood is ideal for building houses and smoke racks, for fueling fishstained cook stoves. For Robinson Kanyek, 33, mangroves were once his sole source of livelihood.

Robinson Kanyek
Robinson KanyekCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Robinson hails from the isolated village of Yonni in Sittia Chiefdom, one of the 11 chiefdoms in Bonthe District. For many years, as a skilled mangrove cutter, local residents would commission him to take his boat out into the murky waters to fell and harvest mangroves for them. Gathering a dozen long mangrove branches in his boat, arms bursting with sinew and eyes wide with pride, he would transport them to market and sell them with his wife, Sadiatu. They used this vital income to provide for their young family.

Illustrated panel of Robinson, a man in a dark polo shirt, holding a machete among tall mangrove roots with a wooden boat on the water behind him.
Robinson’s story re-imagined in graphic novel form

Carbon Credits done right and wrong

In 2023, Robinson was forced to stop cutting mangroves. He lost his income. In that year, a carbon capture project - “Community-Based Mangrove Conservation and Restoration in Sierra Leone” was established in Robinson’s community to promote climate conservationism and “stimulate the local economy”.

In the broader conversation about carbon capture and mitigating climate change - mangroves have long been touted as significant. Mangrove forests reduce and sequester carbon at a rate four times higher than the average tropical rainforests. They also filter pollutants from the water, improving ocean health, and provide breeding grounds for many species of fish and birds.

This project - established by a company called West Africa Blue (via Africa Conservation Initiative or “ACI” as local residents call it) involves the conservation of 10,624 ha of mangroves - roughly 15,000 football pitches or an area the size of Chicago. “After extensive consultation with traditional community authorities and members, West Africa Blue entered into 50-year lease agreements in March 2022 across five chiefdoms”, company documents state - this area included Sittia chiefdom - where Robinson calls home.

Evidence of the project established in Bonthe
Evidence of the project established in BontheCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

For the carbon credits project to work, Robinson and the local residents were ordered to stop cutting mangroves. A local by-law was established by the paramount chief - the traditional leader - and an outright ban on cutting was initiated. That was three years ago. Robinson hasn’t been able to work as a cutter since.

“During the ban a man tried to cut the mangrove trees despite the ACI by-law, but he was caught and forced to pay SLE 4000 ($160), " Robinson explains. “Everyone was scared. Without that money families could not afford to eat”.

Since the ban on cutting, Robinson has turned to fishing. He earns 20 to 30 dollars a month when things are good. Mostly things are not good. He is struggling to survive.

Robinson Kanyek demonstrates his fishing technique
Robinson Kanyek demonstrates his fishing techniqueCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Residents say the company behind the mangrove conservation project has done little to make up for the income they have lost, particularly mangrove cutters and traders. People in Robinson’s village have been promised a share of the profits. But they do not know how much that will be or when it will arrive. Three years after the project began, they say, there are fewer jobs than before.

We approached ACI with a list of questions and offered them a chance to comment on this story before publication. They did not respond.

Illustrated panel of a man in an orange shirt signing papers at a table beside a man in a cap and sunglasses, watched by villagers sitting and standing near a thatched house.
Robinson’s story re-imagined in graphic novel form

Our team of investigative reporters visited 6 of the 11 sections that make up Sittia Chiefdom. In each village, communities complained of the loss of livelihood as a result of the ban on mangrove cutting. They allege that promises made have not yet been kept. Meanwhile, ACI is working to sign up more villages. Every additional hectare means more carbon stored, and more credits to sell.

Christopher S. Sesay, Sittia Chiefdom Secretary, was one of the signatories of the latest agreement in 2025. He is hopeful about the project outcomes, but understands local frustration with the process. “We had big arguments but eventually agreed to take 40% of the profit from the project. But now people are also asking where the profit is. Where the promise of employment is. Everyone is complaining because of the delay of the 40% return. We pray to God that this will happen soon. People here, if they are sick and they don’t have money, they die.”

Robinson’s new hope

Robinson has been forced to adapt to his new life. But a conversation with his brother, one of ACI’s few local employees, gave him an idea. Most days, he walks down the slope at the edge of his village to the local shoreline, where, together with a small group of helpers he pays from his own pockets, he gets to work.

“I now spend 4 hours a day in my free time looking after the mangroves. I plant mangroves seedlings for free, but I hope this will lead to work from the carbon credits company.” Robinson says he has planted almost 3000 mangrove trees as of March 2026.

Robinson instructs mangrove planters
Robinson instructs mangrove plantersCredit: Luisa von Richthofen
Robinson holds mangrove seedlings
Robinson holds mangrove seedlingsCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

It is unclear that Robinson’s efforts will lead to anything. But his resolve is strong. “If God wills it. If fate wills it, I will be remembered for my efforts in this community. Even after I die.”

Robinson hands out mangrove seedlings to his team
Robinson hands out mangrove seedlings to his teamCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Many celebrate this initiative, despite its limitations

In a country shaped by decades of mining, investment that does not dig up the land is a rare opportunity. Back in bustling Freetown, Sonkita Conteh explains the role Namati has played on Sherbro. The organisation, he says, advised the communities on the legal side of the profit sharing agreement and helped secure the 40 percent share.

Namati is no newcomer to land rights. Two members of its Sierra Leone team drafted the Customary Land Rights and National Land Commission Acts, which parliament passed unanimously in 2022 and which significantly strengthened communities’ ability to protect their land and the environment. Now the organisation is drafting a national strategy for the country’s growing number of carbon credit projects.

The Bonthe deal has been held up as a successful and fair model, both at home and abroad. Conteh sees carbon credits as a good option for Sierra Leone. But he would have liked even more revenue and more decision-making power for local residents. And he knows that communities cannot wait forever.

“Two to three years in the making and they’ve not been able to sell the carbon credits. If you want to keep communities interested in carbon projects,” Conteh says, “you simply don’t tell them that, ‘oh, just bear with us until we sell the carbon credits after four years.’”

And yet for Robinson, this is exactly what is happening. All he can do is look to the mainland, and hope.

Despair, resilience and pine - Bukaleba Forest, Uganda

Bukaleba Forest Reserve, Uganda. Open in OpenStreetMap © OpenStreetMap contributors

The field looks ordinary enough: rough grass, a few thornbushes, the red soil of southeastern Uganda. On the right, just a few hundred meters further down the slope: Lake Victoria - the source of the River Nile. On the left, thousands of pine and eucalyptus trees rise in dead-straight rows. The rows are dark and quiet, no animal, no bird to be seen.

Bukaleba Forest Reserve
Bukaleba Forest ReserveCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

This is the edge of the Bukaleba Forest Reserve, one of Africa’s oldest carbon credit projects. Asbert Damba has not set foot here since the afternoon he says he was almost beaten to death. He walks slowly now, retracing his steps for the local council chairman of his village. Here is the place where he stood with his cattle. There, he points, is the direction the men came from with their pangas, a kind of heavy, broad machete in common use across East Africa.

Two illustrated panels: Asbert, wearing a striped scarf, walks beside his cattle through a forest, then looks ahead in alarm as a group of men carrying machetes chase him at sunset.
Asbert’s story re-imagined in graphic novel form

Months on, standing in the open, he is still filled with dread. "I actually feel like they could come and find me standing here and finish me off."

Asbert Damba is in his mid-twenties. The wiry young man with a serious countenance has herded cattle since he was about thirteen years old. The roughly fifty heads of cattle he herds make him the breadwinner of his family. His mother Ruth, his father, younger siblings and his small daughter all depend on that herd. They depend on Asbert.

Asbert Damba
Asbert DambaCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Asbert used to think, while his cattle were grazing, about sending his siblings to school and providing for his own wife and child. But since the attack he can no longer work. The pain in his sides and chest keeps him up at night. Someone else has to herd his cows.

Ruth Damba with their herd
Ruth Damba with their herdCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

His mother, Ruth, still begins her mornings at the kraal. She washes her face, greets the household, milks the cows and sells milk. That money sustains her children. It is a small, fragile economy of survival in the Ugandan countryside. Asbert’s beating tore a hole through it.

Assaulted and afraid

It happened on the Eid holiday this year, March 20th 2026, Damba recounts. He was grazing his animals at the edge of the plantation, not among the trees, he insists. Suddenly, a group of men emerged from the forest. Plantation workers, Damba alleges, set on him with their machetes. He tried to ask what he had done wrong, he says, but the men did not speak the local language. Instead they beat him with the flat of their weapons, Damba alleges.

Illustrated panel of two men in a sunlit forest carrying an injured young man between them by his arms and legs, with a group of men with sticks walking away down the track behind them.
Asbert’s story re-imagined in graphic novel form

When they were done, they took him to the workers' camp inside the plantation. There, Damba says, a man the others treated as the manager began to beat him, too. By the time it was over, his body was covered in wounds. The camp manager brought him back to the village on his motorcycle, dropped him off at the police station and promptly left.

The village policemen, Damba alleges, were not interested in taking his statement. He was told, in effect, to find his own way to treatment. Injured and without money, he made his way to Mayuge, the district town, with his mother, where they reported the case. We were able to view the police report, a rare piece of documentation for an attack like this.

To understand why a herdsman would be attacked for grazing at the edge of a forest plantation, you have to understand what the forest is. The Bukaleba Forest Reserve is state land, but in the 1990s the Ugandan government leased it to a Norwegian company called Green Resources, first to grow timber and later to sell carbon credits.

The company, so it claims on its website, is East Africa’s largest forest development and wood processing company. Bukaleba is one of the oldest plantation carbon projects in Africa. The project began in 2004, and its 42-year crediting period runs until 2046. It converts fast-growing trees, eucalyptus and pine trees, into carbon credits, which are sold to companies far from Uganda.

Green Resources is now held, through an African forestry investment platform, by the international asset manager New Forests. Credits from the plantation are still on the market today.

Green Resources activities
Green Resources activitiesCredit: Julius Mugambwa

Many of the families who farm around the plantation were there first, but they hold no land titles. Ruth Damba says she arrived in the village of Nakalanga around 2000. There was no plantation at the edge of the village then, she says, only bush, which she cleared to plant maize, sweet potatoes and sugarcane. Then the company came and planted its trees over her fields.

The Ugandan state later set aside 500 hectares for the communities - squeezed between the reserve and the lake, adjacent to the village of Nakalanga where Asbert and his family live. But the population has now grown massively, the shoreline soil is fertile, desired and contested. There is also an agreement between the villagers and the Norwegian company allowing villagers into the forest to occasionally fetch firewood. That zone between what belongs to the people and what belongs to the plantation is where conflicts happen.

Asbert is not the only one. The former council chairman in Nakalanga, Michael Wananda , describes a relationship with the plantation that has spiralled – into mistrust and intermittent violence. Residents, he says, have learned to move near the forest the way that prey moves. "Right now we are like guinea fowl chicks," he tells us. "We go there but we are very alert. When we see them we run, but sometimes they get you."

Wananda Michael, Former Council Chairman
Wananda Michael, Former Council ChairmanCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

The community sees no benefit from carbon credits

The community says promises made by the company, which included a stipend for the neighbours of the forest, collaborative management of the trees and a health center, have not materialised. "We haven't received anything to date," Michael says. Neighbouring villages, he adds, receive an annual payment; his village does not. The most recent violent flare-up, he believes, came in the weeks after a large timber harvest, when the company grew watchful over its trees and tempers frayed on both sides.

For our investigation, we spoke with multiple residents of Nakalanga. Three women told us that they, too, had been beaten in the forest within the last three years. They spoke on condition of anonymity and we were not able to verify their accounts independently. What is certain: none of these cases reached a court of law; most, unlike Asbert's, were not properly documented.

This pattern is not new to researchers either: rights groups have for years documented land conflict and allegations of violence around Green Resources' Ugandan plantations, a phenomenon one report from the Oakland Institute called "carbon violence."

Asbert’s case is still open. Its only result so far has been an order that the men who beat him pay for his treatment. The money did not cover it. Asbert still owes the clinic. No one has been charged. Many of the men, he says, are still working in the area. The manager who allegedly beat Asbert sometimes passes by the family home on his way from the campsite and he just smiles, Ruth confirms."I don't have a word I would say to him. I'd just look at him, because I know he is more powerful than me," she says, eyes downcast.

Ruth Damba holds the police medical report that shows Asbert’s wounds
Ruth Damba holds the police medical report that shows Asbert’s woundsCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

We put these allegations to Busoga Forestry Company, which operates the plantation, and to its owners, Green Resources. They did not respond by the time of publication.

Trucks carry felled pine branches
Trucks carry felled pine branchesCredit: Julius Mugambwa

Above the village, where Asbert was beaten, the pine trees sway lightly in the warm lakeside breeze. The trees are, at this moment, doing exactly what they were planted to do. They stand, they grow, and they store the precious carbon that is sold as a climate virtue thousands of kilometers away. The hidden price of that clean conscience, however, lies heavy on the Damba family and their neighbours.

Resistance, Family feuds and Soil - Kajiado, Kenya

If you drive 95km south of Nairobi - across and over the rolling hills where Kenya’s long distance running champions train, you will eventually arrive in the flat lands of Oldonyonyokie, Kajiado County. This is Maasai territory.

Oldonyonyokie, Kajiado County
Oldonyonyokie, Kajiado CountyCredit: Chrispin Omuko

The arid grasslands, north of Lake Magadi, are home to numerous Maasai Group Ranches who have lived there for generations - over 1000 households in total. It’s early morning and the movement of cattle can be seen beyond the acacia trees, herds advancing steadily towards the nearby mountain. Emerging from a muddy thatched structure is Francis Lelit, a youth leader in the Oldonyonyokie community.

Francis Lelit
Francis LelitCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

It’s been a turbulent year for the residents of Oldonyonyokie, and Francis has been at the centre of it all. He has a story to tell. A story of a family divided and a generational wound cleft open.

In January 2026, Senior reporter Martin Siele at Africa Uncensored explored part of this story in the “Carbon Colony: The Battle for Ownership Of Maasai Land” investigation. He uncovered how Maasai are often being displaced as a consequence of carbon credit initiatives started by wealthy elites. The Kajiado Rangelands Carbon Project (KRCP) was the focus of that investigation. Our story follows up on that critical investigation, further showing the human impact of the carbon project and how a family came to near deadly blows.

Carbon credits in Kajiado County

It all began in May 2023, when a company called Soils for the Future Africa arrived to strike a deal with the Oldonyonyokie community. “The country director came with the ward co-ordinator. We had our first meeting. They told us about their projects and what they do,” Francis recalls. Soils for the Future is one of the dominant players in the carbon offsetting business in East Africa.

KRCP wasn’t Soils for the Future’s first foray in Kenya and their activities have caused much controversy. The organization was also behind the Northern Kenya Rangelands Carbon Project, which sold credits to companies including Meta and Netflix. In 2025, carbon certifier Verra suspended the project after a Kenyan court ruled that two conservancies set up by NRT on community land were unconstitutional. Verra reinstated the project in June 2026.

Kajiado County, Kenya. View on Datawrapper

For the residents of Oldonyonyokie, the incentive of Soils for the Future’s involvement was clear. Many in the community had long wanted to sub-divide and own the land, but surveying it was expensive. The project, it was said, would cover the fees and then generate revenue for everyone. “They said they would compensate the community with huge amounts of money”, Francis alleges, “if we signed for 40 years”.

Joseph Masia Sankaire is Francis’s paternal uncle. A member of the elmirishi age-set, he was a supporter of the project from the beginning. “Some of us could not afford the land sub-division fees. There are orphans, widows, people with disabilities and poor people amongst us who were unable to pay in order to get their portions of land”, Joseph explains. People needed money.

Joseph Sankaire, Francis Lelits’ uncle
Joseph Sankaire, Francis Lelits’ uncleCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Concerned youth

As the project negotiations began, a generational rift soon emerged. One of the main issues was indeed money, but also a lack of youth participation. Joseph admits that the elders organized meetings and did not involve the younger members of the community. “We agreed on the amount of money the company would contribute to various group ranch projects such as bursaries and the subdivision fees. The young people opposed the project because when we formed a committee to manage the money, we did not involve them. Yet they also wanted to benefit from it.”

Francis and his close friend Gideon Kanchory, another youth leader in the community, were worried about more than missing out on the project’s profits. They were concerned about what the agreement would mean for their future. Gideon recalls asking: “How is it going to affect my way of life?” When Soils for the Future Africa did not answer, the young men grew suspicious. “We knew there’s more than what meets the eye.”

Gideon Kanchory
Gideon KanchoryCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Francis and Gideon formed their own committee to directly communicate with Soils for the Future. Emails were exchanged and the youth demanded to see a copy of the legal agreement. “When we received the confidential agreement, you could clearly see very contentious clauses,” Gideon explains.

Gideon alleges that the language in the documents was language that “cannot be understood by a layman. It needed scrutiny by a legal practitioner.” Francis and Gideon were also concerned that their elders didn’t understand what they were signing, not having been properly schooled.

Two illustrated panels: a close-up of a hand holding a smartphone showing a photo of a young man in a shawl, and a man in a brimmed hat staring at his own phone with a worried expression.
Francis and Gideon’s story re-imagined in comic form

Francis and Gideon’s concerns were further exacerbated by their research online. They read about the struggles of communities in Northern Kenya, including those impacted by the Northern Rangelands Project, the controversial project that met local and legal resistance. “On social media we learned about other areas. Our Maasai brothers and sisters in Samburu and Laikipia accepted these projects and their land was fenced off,” Francis explains. Francis and Gideon grew concerned this would happen to them. “It will reach a time when we will be chased away from the fenced areas”.

For many young people in Oldonyonyokie, the stakes were existential. Changing how their cattle graze, and risking the fencing and subdivision of land, threatened both their livelihoods and their culture.

Livestock is at the heart of Maasai life. Cattle, goats and sheep are far more than property. They are savings, insurance against hard times and a sign of status. For many families, a herd is worth much more than money in the bank. In this dry, drought-prone landscape, animals roam widely to find grass and water. That is why there are hardly any fences. Any rule on where and when herds may graze touches the core of this way of life.

“Seeing my Maasai brothers giving away their land in other areas. It makes me very worried and sad,” Francis explains. Francis and Gideon allege that they communicated their concerns to Soils for the Future, but their protestations fell on deaf ears. They were further excluded from meetings. When the local elders decided to proceed with the project, Francis and Gideon decided they had to take drastic action.

Disrespect and war

The treaty was to be signed on a local field on April 30, 2025. Over 500 youth gathered early in the morning in the bushes near the signing location. They were determined to stop the ceremony, whatever the cost. The youth, and the elders, were all willing to fight.

When Joseph and the elders arrived at the meeting place, they had no idea of the trouble that was brewing. “We were oblivious,” Joseph recalls. An argument soon turned into a violent confrontation. Among the young men on the other side, Joseph says, was Francis, his own nephew. Shocked, Joseph had no time to try to talk. He too was hit by a stone and rushed to hospital.

Two illustrated panels of Maasai men in red shukas fighting at sunset, swinging sticks and hurling stones at a line of men running away across open ground.
Francis and Gideon’s story re-imagined in comic form

“It was a heavy war where stones were being thrown, and sticks were all over. Hitting an elderly person is terrible. It’s taboo,” Gideon remembers. “But, you are hitting them. If the stones get to your brother. So be it.” Gideon and Francis say that 11 people were taken to hospital that day.

“There was so much intensity that they had to run away. All of them.”, Gideon remembers, with a hint of glee in his eyes. Quickly, the ceremony was halted and the signing abandoned. The company workers were forced to flee the location.

The aftermath

After the conflict, Francis and many of the perpetrators of the attack had to suffer the consequences of their actions. A taboo was broken - for respect of the elders is a pillar of Maasai culture. This rift ran right through Francis’ family as Joseph recovered from an injured shoulder. “I was very angry. I stayed home for three days and barely ate or spoke to anyone. It felt terrible that someone I considered my child would take up arms against me,” Joseph remembers with sadness.

Francis family homestead at the base of the mountain
Francis family homestead at the base of the mountainCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Across the Oldonyonyokie community, youths were frozen out and ignored by their elders. This was a source of deep shame to the Maasai youth, which took over a year to reconcile.

Reconciliation in Spring 2026

“According to the Maasai culture, young men should show reconciliation by gifting the elders with this type of shawl. We were over 300 (elders) in number,” Joseph explains. In April of 2026, the community finally found agreement to put the event behind them and Francis gifted his uncle a shuka shawl. “They also slaughtered some fat cows for us and we ate and drank together. We were very happy. We pronounced a blessing for each of them and went home.”

Joseph and Francis discuss his “shuka” - gifted by Francis
Joseph and Francis discuss his “shuka” - gifted by FrancisCredit: Luisa von Richthofen

Joseph is mournful but upbeat about the incident. “Upon reflection, I thought I must have wronged him in a big way to warrant such anger. Although it wasn’t right to attack the elders, his anger must have been justified. I might be older than him, but he can correct me when I’m wrong.”

What next for the project?

For Joseph this is a lesson learned that the youth must be included in discussions. It was agreed to end involvement in the project. “As the community elders, we resolved that any further agreements with Soils for the Future should be between the organization and individual land owners; not the entire community.”

Soils for the Future insisted to Francis and Gideon that they involved the youth in the project to a satisfactory extent. In emails to Gideon and Francis they describe that the internal conflict is nothing to do with them. We offered Soils for the Future Africa an opportunity to give us their version of events. They did not respond.

Oldonyonyokie Group Ranch has now been removed from the project.

An uncertain future

Across Sherbro, Bukaleba and Oldonyonyokie, the same questions remain: who controls the land, who collects the money, and who will compensate the community for what they’re lost. Robinson, Asbert and Francis are still waiting to see the benefits they were promised.